Medigap companies file their prices with each state, along with the claims behind them. We read of these rate filings from states. In short, in our middle estimate, Plan N's discount shrinks over time but doesn't go away, and most of High-Deductible G's discount lasts.
Why the two plans start cheaper
Part of it is the coverage. Plan N has copays, and High-Deductible G has you pay the first $3,050 of the year yourself. The rest is who buys them. People who pick these plans tend to be healthier, so they cost the company less in claims.
Lately, they've gone up less than Plan G
Across the industry, from 2020 through 2026, Plan N's average yearly increase was about percentage points lower than Plan G's, and High-Deductible G's about points lower. In the filings we checked, when a company raised Plan G and Plan N at the same time, they got the same increase % of the time, and Plan N got the smaller increase more often than the bigger one.
The healthier-buyer edge shrinks, but much of it stays
Filings that follow the same people year by year show that edge wearing off fast: within about three to six years, Plan N pays out about as large a share of what it charges as Plan G does. The filings show companies already expect that early catch-up when they set prices, so it's built in. What's left after it tends to last. Across comparisons of a company's Plan N with its own Plan G in states, people on Plan N cost about % as much in claims as people on Plan G in a typical comparison. Across comparisons for High-Deductible G, it was about %.
What we assume
Typically, Plan N kept about % of the healthier-buyer advantage built into its starting price, and our middle estimate uses that. High-Deductible G typically kept all of its advantage, and to be careful we assume it keeps 90%.
What that means for prices
Where it could turn out differently
Results vary a lot by company, especially for Plan N. In the middle half of those comparisons, people on Plan N cost % to % as much in claims as people on Plan G, and in , Plan N cost as much as Plan G or more. In older high-deductible plans, prices have also risen more slowly than claims, so some catch-up increases are likely. That's why these are middle estimates, and why you can change them above.